Depreciation
What is depreciation?
Suppose our business buys a computer for $2,300 and at the end of 3 years finds that the software
applications have grown in size so much that we need a faster computer with a bigger hard drive.
Our business then buys a new computer and sells the old one for $200. Since the first computer
dropped in value by $2300 - $200 = $2100 over 3 years, at the rate of $700 per year, we can say:
- the life of the computer was 3 years
- the total depreciation was $2100
- the annual depreciation was $700
What would our books show?
During the life of the computer, our bookkeeper would record an annual depreciation
of $700, and subtract that from our fixed assets each year. At the end of 3 years,
its book value would be $200, matched by its selling price of $200, and the books would
balance.
If we remember the previous chapter's paragraphs on capital expenditure,
and that capital expenditure is not written into the books as a short-term cost,
we see that depreciation gives us a way of distributing capital expenditure over
the life of the asset. Depreciation is both:
- an annual reduction in the value of a fixed asset for its economic life
- the initial capital expenditure minus its end resale value,
distributed over the anticipated economic life of the asset.
This definition differs from the Australian official definition (AAS4 and AASB1021):
Depreciation is the measure of the wearing out, consumption or other reduction
in the useful economic life of a fixed asset whether arising from use, effluxion of time or
obsolescence through technological or market changes.
This interprets depreciation to be, not a monetary value, but a "measure of the wearing out".
A realistic definition would be better.
A more useful definition is that given foreconomic life:
The useful economic life of an asset is the period over which
the present owner will derive economic benefits from its use.
However, anticipating the future is difficult. Suppose our bookkeeper had expected that our computer,
at the end of 3 years, would sell for $1000 ? The annual depreciation would then be
written into our books as $1200/3years = $400 p.a.(per annum/per year). When our computer sold
for only $200 our books would not balance. Somehow we need to account for that $1000 - $200 = $800
difference.
A further problem arises if the computer is replaced at the end of 2 years or 4 years.
How do we adjust our books?
What if the equipment is a truck which is expected to last 10 years?
Vehicles lose a big slice of their value in the first year, then diminishing smaller slices in following years.
Taking off equal amounts each year is not an accurate way of assessing their depreciation.
Does this matter as long as the books balance at the end ?
Inflation has an effect on valuing assets. Inflation is a meazure of the rising cost (over time).
When prices rise across most goods and services, money buys less, and this devaluation of money is called inflation. In contrast to this,
the prices of electronic equipment, such as televisions and computers, fall with their increasing scale of production
(not to mention competition); so that prices fall over time. A computer worth $3000 when first on the market,
is worth perhaps $300, only 3 years later.
Accounting accommodates these changes in value, by revaluing assets periodically.
In Australia, such increases in the value of assets (due to inflation) cannot be applied to profit/loss accounts.
Otherwise that trick could be used to hide a loss from shareholders. While the price of food usually rises all the time, the price of equipment might rise or fall,
particularly for imported equipment during currency fluctuations.
Re-evaluations must go into a separate account called 'Revaluation reserve'.
If inflation runs high, we might buy at $80,000 and sell at $100,000 yet the truck,
as its maintenance costs increase, is obviously not as good as when new. And what about land ?
With these questions, we can expect different accountants to
take different approaches to depreciation. (Except for land - land does not depreciate.)
In assessing depreciation, what factors are involved ?
- (initial) capital expenditure
- (final) resale value
- economic life
- how to assess each year's reduction in value.
There are several methods for assessing each year's depreciation, but,
once one method is selected, it must be used consistently throughout the life of the asset.
And of course, your method is explained in the attachment to your annual balance sheet.
Some depreciation methods are:
- market value
- constant dollar value
equal $ amounts
- constant percentage
equal percentage reduction (diminishing $ amounts)
- sum-of-years method
diminishing $ amounts
- unit of depletion method
for assets which are used at fluctuating rates
(mineral or oil deposits, quarries; even machinery
whose life is meazured in running hours instead of years)
- revaluation method
For collections of low-cost items, portions of which need frequent replacement
(because of damage or theft, etc)
Market value
Using market value has several problems:
- how do we gauge market value ?
- market value fluctuates because of fashion, currency valuations, etc
- the value of an asset to a business is independent
of market value except at the beginning when it is bought, and at the end when it is sold
- depreciation is not an assessment of the fall in market value,
but an assessment of its reducing effective cost to the business through its economic life
- why waste time trying to assess the market value of every fixed asset - keep it simple.
Click to see the graph.
Constant dollar value
This constant $ value or straight-line method uses:
Depreciation = (buying price - selling price)/life in years.
This is a simple and common way of distributing the initial capital expenditure (minus
its end resale value) over the anticipated economic life of the asset.
Click to see the graph.
Constant percentage
This constant % depreciation or reducing-balance method, involves equal percentage reduction but diminishing $ amounts. If n = economic life in years,
annual depreciation percentage = ((nth root of (capital expenditure - residual value)) - 1)
This is easily done with a scientific calculator. Without a scientific calculator, it is easy to do several runs
from the bottom to the top, adjusting the percentage, using the formula:
residual value = capital expenditure x (1 - depreciation% as a decimal)x(1 - depreciation% as a decimal)x ...(1 - depreciation% as a decimal)
with as many (1 - depreciation% as a decimal) as there are full years.
Example:
- capital expenditure = $1000
- residual value = $100
- economic life = 5 years
- first try depreciation = 40% = 0.40
- therefore, after 1 year, value = 60% = 0.60
$1000 x 0.6 x 0.6 x 0.6 x 0.6 x 0.6 = $77.76 which is< $100
- if answer is too low decrease depreciation = 30% = 0.70
$1000 x 0.7 x 0.7 x 0.7 x 0.6 x 0.7 = $168.07 which is > $100
- if answer is too high increase depreciation = 35% = 0.35
$1000 x 0.65 x 0.65 x 0.65 x 0.65 x 0.65 = $ which is > $116.03
Keep going till you find that a depreciation of 37% gives a residual value of $99.24.
By using a constant % depreciation, the dollar-value of the depreciation
diminishes. The first year sees the greatest absolute depreciation in dollars, while the last year sees the smallest.
This is how assets actually depreciate. Further, the reductions in the last years are small,
so the difference between them and the realised residual value, will be small.
Click to see the graph.
Sum-of-years method
Example:
- capital expenditure = $1000
- residual value = $100
- economic life = 5 years
If the life is 5 years, add the series: 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 = 15.
Calculate depreciation, going backwards:
| Year |
1st year |
2nd year |
3rd year |
4th year |
5th year |
| Depreciation |
5/15 |
4/15 |
3/15 |
2/15 |
1/15 |
| Reduced value |
700 |
460 |
280 |
160 |
100 |
Remember it is 5/15 of ($1000 - $100), of capital expenditure minus residual value.
As in the reducing balance method, this is how assets actually depreciate.
Further, the reductions in the last years are small,
so the difference between them and the realised residual value, will be small.
Click to see the graph.
Unit-of-depletion method
The unit-of-depletion method is for assets which are used at fluctuating rates
such as mineral or oil deposits, quarries, and even machinery
whose life is meazured in running hours instead of in years.
Obviously the graph diminishes but its shape is variable, from horizontal if no mining is done,
to very steep for big mining of small reserves.
Click to see the graph.
Revaluation method
The revaluation method is for collections of low-cost items, portions of which need frequent replacement
because of damage or theft, etc. Example are: bedding in hotels, dinner sets in restaurants,
salt and pepper shakers at our university refectory, tools in a workshop.
Add purchases of replacements to the book value
the method used is usually:
- at the beginning of the year you have the book value from the previous year
- during the year, add purchases of replacements to the book value
- at the end of the year, value all
- write off the difference between last year's book value and this year's,
as an expense
This 'method' is nothing more than a simple workaround for low-cost items which need
repeated replacement.
Click to see the graph.
Several points should be noted:
- for all methods, When the disposal or resale value differs from the depreciated book value,
this difference is recorded as a profit or loss
- depreciation methods do not help to replace the assets at their use-by date
- different methods have different significant effects on the book value performance
between and within years - when reading the balance sheet, study the notes on depreciation!
- none of the above methods accounts for inflation,
but an occasional revaluation of assets is usually taken
(particularly when trying to hide poor profits for the year)
- depreciation is listed in the profit/loss account but not in the cash book
because the purchase is a one-off capital expenditure.