Fixed and variable costs
What are fixed costs? What are variable costs?
Suppose our business manufactures everything from scissors to tractors.
What if some of those items are making huge profits but some are making losses.
Those lines making losses should be made profitable by reducing costs or by increasing prices.
If that is not possible they should be abandoned, and their resources, including retrained staff,
should be switched to the profitable lines. All that is obvious.
What is not obvious when costs are not separated but all lumped together, is which lines are losing.
Therefore we need to separate the costs for each line. Where do we begin?
Suppose we closed the factory and produced nothing for 12 months. For those 12 months,
we would still have to pay rent and rates (outgoings),
hire people to maintain the equipment and buildings, probably pay for some power for maintenance,
pay for the phone line rental for the odd call, pay security guards, and, at the end of 12 months
of producing nothing, our equipment would be 12 months older and 12 months closer
to obsolescence, closer to replacement should we re-open.
All those costs are fixed costs, costs that occur with or without production.
Let us re-open our factory to manufacture 100 tractors. We buy the steel, hire the staff,
buy more power, etc. If we double production, we will need more steel, more power, more staff.
These costs increase and decrease as production increases and decreases. These are variable costs.
Fixed costs are the minimum running cost of a complete factory before production.
Variable costs are those costs beginning at zero with zero production, and increasing with actual production. Variable costs are not usually directly proportional to production because initially the variable cost per unit output usually decreases as production increases, till it reaches a minimum cost due to maximum efficiency, then increases.
A manager of a small but expanding Australian airline said he could compete with the 'big boys' because of his higher efficiency.
This efficiency would increase until the number of his planes reached 50. Bigger than that, he said, and his efficiency would drop and so would his profits.
That would be the best time to sell his airline to the 'big boys'. He did.
He sold to a 'big boy' who later went bankrupt.
A little known Aussie battler has made a series of very successful (multi-million dollar) businesses by always competing with huge monopolies. His success, he claims, is due to
his greater efficiency, his ability to spend time with his clients, study them and thus satisfy their needs.
In graphs, we use $ to denote dollars, and $'000 to denote thousands of dollars.
Click for graph of fixed costs.
Click for graph of variable costs.
An important tool is the ability to add and subtract graphs. Think of graphs as a series of vertical lines,
each vertical line giving the $ value. Add the vertical lines for fixed cost and variable cost
to obtain the vertical line for total cost.
Click for graph of total costs.
Now we come to the interesting part. We can use fixed and variable costs
to calculate the minimum production needed to break even, that is to make zero profits,
neither losing nor profiting.
Break-even charts
Fixed costs are constant, that is, remain the same all the time (otherwise they are
not fixed). On a graph or chart, fixed costs make a horizontal line across the page.
Variable costs go up with production. Revenue is zero at zero production and, we hope, increases
with production (assuming every unit sells). At some number of units produced,
the revenue will equal the total of fixed and variable costs.
Revenue - total costs = zero.
We break even. This is the break-even point.
If we produce fewer than this number of units, total costs > revenue, and our factory makes a loss.
If we produce more than this number of units, total costs< revenue, and our factory makes a profit.
Subtract the vertical line for total cost from the vertical line for revenue,
to obtain the vertical line for profit/loss.
Click for graph of revenue minus cost.
The cost per unit introduces another factory tool.
If the fixed cost is $1,000,000, making one tractor is very expensive at $1,000,000 per tractor.
Making 1000 tractors spreads the fixed costs, so that the fixed cost is $1000 per tractor.
Over 1,000,000 tractors is only $1 per tractor.
In addition, there is the variable cost. For one tractor the variable cost may be $100,000
because you buy metal in minimum quantities, perhaps enough to make 100 tractors.
You have to get the whole factory running for one tractor as well as for 1000 tractors.
therefore the variable cost spread over 1000 tractors reduces the variable cost per tractor.
Add the fixed cost per tractor to the variable cost per tractor to obtain the total cost per tractor.
Click for graph of costs per unit.
Note how the cost per unit drops with the increasing efficiencies which come with increasing production,
up to a point. After a certain size, efficiency begins to drop, as lines of communication
lengthen and become less personal, as de-personalization lowers morale,
as improvements to production slow and maintenance becomes more difficult (the list is endless).
In our true airline example, the lowest cost per unit (cost per passenger-kilometre)
occurred with 50 planes. The 'big boys' who went bankrupt, should have looked at
their cost-per-unit graphs more carefully. (Do not take this too literally, since the
carrier industry is much more complicated.)
How do you draw such a cost-per-unit graph? Some difficulties are:
- graphs which predict (extrapolate), are unreliable (they usually lie)
- graphs which use valid evidence (interpolate), are historical and too late
- graphs are tools, not decision-makers
- graphs do not accommodate future changes in costs and revenue caused by:
- new technology (not always an improvement)
- more or less personal management-staff relations and communications
- better or worse morale
- aging of equipment
- externally changing markets, government taxes etc
- inflation
- currency exchange rates changing cost of imports, exports.
The list of variables seems endless. Each graph gives only a snapshot frozen in the past.
They are useful tools, but their usefulness depends on the competence of those who use them.
Never use a graph as an excuse for a bad decision. No tool is perfect;
each has an area of uncertainty callederror. If we use a tape meazure to determine
the length of a house as 12.375m there is an error range of +/-0.5mm.
This gives us an accuracy of 1 in 24,750. If we use it to meazure the thickness of my book on electricity,
we have 110.5mm+/-0.5mm, an accuracy of 1 in 221. Good. Now let us use it to meazure
the thickness of a hair. The same tool gives us different reliability according to
how we use it. It is our method of using the tool which determines its accuracy.
Never blame the graph.
End of Fixed and variable costs.