Argument – true, dishonest, false

Definition
What is an argument?
An argument is NOT a quarrel.
An argument is a step by step use of the rules of logic, to go from information to conclusion.

How do we prove something is true? There are more methods of arguing, such as:
Imported arguments
Often authors 'quote' famous people, and just as often misquote them, putting in their mouths the words that support their own prejudices. In any case, being famous does not make people more intelligent, more knowledgeable or less prejudiced. It certainly didn't help George W Bush. But he and the Commission examining the Central Intelligence Agency did show us that Truth is inversely proportional to the money outcome. So always query the author, his logic, his knowledge and his prejudice, particularly his revenue stream.

Another ploy is to use the conclusions of others without quoting the source, so you cannot verify the accuracy of the quote. Another is to call on 'experts', people with heaps of qualifications but little practical experience, such as those whose prejudice has persuaded juries to send innocent people to jail. (Example: the Australian Lindy Chamberlain case)

The only sound reason for quoting someone else is to avoid repeating a long argument already convincingly handled. The source must be given and its author must be not simply be experienced in the area of the argument but must fully and logically argue the case based on sound evidence. Otherwise the quotation is worthless, except as propaganda.

Do not assume that researchers or scientists are correct. Many a scientist has: Example: scientists whose research 'proved' that smoking tobacco was not harmful. Surprise! Surprise! Their research was sponsored by tobacco companies. The companies were eventually fined big dollars for falsifying their conclusions.

In contrast, we should not reject ideas because they are strange or because we do not understand the logic or concepts behind them. Copernicus, Galileo, Darwin, Wegener, Einstein, and countless others have been ridiculed by the experts of their day, but now their ideas are popular (even to people who do not understand them). Better to adopt a policy of modesty towards new ideas, and reserve judgement until we can refute them logically, that is, to tie facts into a logical argument to show that such a thing is not possible. [Methods of arguing are given later.]
Information
All information presented is limited and therefore selected. We choose the information from masses of information available. We select what is most relevant to our needs, that is, to prove what we want to prove. We design our experiments to prove what we want to prove. In selecting information or experiments, our bias is at work, whether we like it or not. Because of this, most analyses are predominantly propaganda – whether we like it or not. It is interesting, over the decades, to observe how scientific conclusions have changed with the fashions in scientific opinion.

At first, I found this concept unpalatable; but accepting it, changed my writing. It also helps to reduce that bias and allows me to warn my readers. We should see it in ourselves and in the authors we read. It is with difficulty that we can present both sides of an argument with equal fervor, and then let the reader choose their own conclusion. If we are writing an analysis for our boss, this presenting both sides for his decision might be the best procedure because his biases may be markedly different to ours. (We can hope we would be less partial and therefore more ethical.)
Dishonest argument I give this chapter on dishonest argument because it is important to realize how other people argue and to be aware of what you can suffer when faced by ruthless people. In particular, many good people, particularly whistleblowers, have had their reputations destroyed by ruthless media, corporations, unions and other powerful organizations by use of dishonest argument.

Those of you who have studied logic already know the standard methods of derailing a discussion by deflecting attention to extraneous and irrelevant matters:
Fallacies of argument Here is a wonderful list of fallacies drawn from the experience of Stephen Downes of Brandon, Manitoba, Canada.
Also visit Stephen's Guide to the Logical Fallacies
which gives a great, concise definition with example, of almost every logic fallacy listed below.
This is fact recognition, accurate cogitation, correct thinking, proper logic, and true deduction from the University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
 
A. Fallacies of Distraction
False DilemmaTwo choices are given when in fact there are three options.
From IgnoranceBecause something is not known to be true, it is assumed to be false.
Slippery SlopeA series of increasingly unacceptable consequences is drawn.
Complex QuestionTwo unrelated points are conjoined as a single proposition.
B. Appeals to Motives in Place of Support
Appeal to ForceThe reader is persuaded to agree by force.
Appeal to PityThe reader is persuaded to agree by sympathy.
ConsequencesThe reader is warned of unacceptable consequences.
Prejudicial LanguageValue or moral goodness is attached to believing the author.
PopularityA proposition is argued to be true because it is widely held to be true.
C. Changing the Subject
Attacking the Person(1) the person's character is attacked.
(2) the person's circumstances are noted.
(3) the person does not practice what is preached.
Appeal to Authority(1) the authority is not an expert in the field.
(2) experts in the field disagree.
(3) the authority was joking, drunk, or in some other way not being serious.
Anonymous AuthorityThe authority in question is not named.
Style Over SubstanceThe manner in which an argument (or arguer) is presented is felt to affect the truth of the conclusion.
D. Inductive Fallacies
Hasty GeneralizationThe sample is too small to support an inductive generalization about a population
Unrepresentative SampleThe sample is unrepresentative of the sample as a whole.
False AnalogyThe two objects or events being compared are relevantly dissimilar.
Slothful InductionThe conclusion of a strong inductive argument is denied despite the evidence to the contrary.
Fallacy of ExclusionEvidence which would change the outcome of an inductive argument is excluded from consideration.
E. Fallacies Involving Statistical Syllogisms
AccidentA generalization is applied when circumstances suggest that there should be an exception.
Converse AccidentAn exception is applied in circumstances where a generalization should apply.
F. Causal Fallacies
Post HocBecause one thing follows another, it is held to be caused by the other.
Joint effectOne thing is held to cause another when in fact they are both the joint effects of an underlying cause.
InsignificantOne thing is held to cause another, and it does, but it is insignificant compared to other causes of the effect.
Wrong DirectionThe direction between cause and effect is reversed.
Complex CauseThe cause identified is only a part of the entire cause of the effect.
G. Missing the Point
Begging the QuestionThe truth of the conclusion is assumed by the premises.
Irrelevant ConclusionAn argument in defense of one conclusion instead proves a different conclusion.
Straw ManThe author attacks an argument different from (and weaker than) the opposition's best argument.
H. Fallacies of Ambiguity
Equivocation The same term is used with two different meanings.
AmphibolyThe structure of a sentence allows two different interpretations.
AccentThe emphasis on a word or phrase suggests a meaning contrary to what the sentence actually says.
I. Category Errors
CompositionBecause the attributes of the parts of a whole have a certain property, it is argued that the whole has that property.
DivisionBecause the whole has a certain property, it is argued that the parts have that property.
J. Non Sequitur
Affirming the ConsequentAny argument of the form: If A then B, B, therefore A.
Denying the AntecedentAny argument of the form: If A then B, Not A, thus Not B.
InconsistencyAsserting that contrary or contradictory statements are both true.
K. Syllogistic Errors
Fallacy of Four TermsA syllogism has four terms.
Undistributed MiddleTwo separate categories are said to be connected because they share a common property.
Illicit MajorThe predicate of the conclusion talks about all of something, but the premises only mention some cases of the term in the predicate.
Illicit MinorThe subject of the conclusion talks about all of something, but the premises only mention some cases of the term in the subject.
Fallacy of Exclusive PremisesA syllogism has two negative premises.
False PremiseDrawing an affirmative conclusion from a false premise.
Unstated PremiseUnstated premise may be false.
Existential FallacyA particular conclusion is drawn from universal premises.
L. Fallacies of Explanation
Subverted SupportThe phenomenon being explained doesn't exist.
NonsupportEvidence for the phenomenon being explained is biased.
UntestabilityThe theory which explains cannot be tested.
Limited ScopeThe theory which explains can only explain one thing.
Limited DepthThe theory which explains does not appeal to underlying causes.
M. Fallacies of Definition
ExplanationThe definition is an explanation instead of a definition.
A definition has 2 parts:
  • inclusive – A cat is a member of the Genus Felis
  • exclusive – which purrs.
The inclusive part, Genus Felis, must be pre-defined.
Too BroadThe definition includes items which should not be included.
UniversalThe 'definition' is so broad that it becomes vague.
Too NarrowThe definition does not include all the items which should be included.
Failure to ElucidateThe definition is more difficult to understand than the word or concept being defined.
Circular DefinitionThe definition includes the term being defined as a part of the definition.
Conflicting ConditionsThe definition is self-contradictory.
N. Broken-Chain Fallacy
Omits part of argumentThe speaker argues that:
A ⇒ B ⇒ C ⇒ D
and then proves A ⇒ B, C ⇒ D
but does not prove B ⇒ C.
Example: the book The Reformation which purports to prove that the Reformation was a religious revolt when it was driven instead by mostly economic and political motives.