| A. Fallacies of Distraction | |
|---|---|
| False Dilemma | Two choices are given when in fact there are three options. |
| From Ignorance | Because something is not known to be true, it is assumed to be false. |
| Slippery Slope | A series of increasingly unacceptable consequences is drawn. |
| Complex Question | Two unrelated points are conjoined as a single proposition. |
| B. Appeals to Motives in Place of Support | |
| Appeal to Force | The reader is persuaded to agree by force. |
| Appeal to Pity | The reader is persuaded to agree by sympathy. |
| Consequences | The reader is warned of unacceptable consequences. |
| Prejudicial Language | Value or moral goodness is attached to believing the author. |
| Popularity | A proposition is argued to be true because it is widely held to be true. |
| C. Changing the Subject | |
| Attacking the Person | (1) the person's character is attacked.
(2) the person's circumstances are noted. (3) the person does not practice what is preached. |
| Appeal to Authority | (1) the authority is not an expert in the field.
(2) experts in the field disagree. (3) the authority was joking, drunk, or in some other way not being serious. |
| Anonymous Authority | The authority in question is not named. |
| Style Over Substance | The manner in which an argument (or arguer) is presented is felt to affect the truth of the conclusion. |
| D. Inductive Fallacies | |
| Hasty Generalization | The sample is too small to support an inductive generalization about a population |
| Unrepresentative Sample | The sample is unrepresentative of the sample as a whole. |
| False Analogy | The two objects or events being compared are relevantly dissimilar. |
| Slothful Induction | The conclusion of a strong inductive argument is denied despite the evidence to the contrary. |
| Fallacy of Exclusion | Evidence which would change the outcome of an inductive argument is excluded from consideration. |
| E. Fallacies Involving Statistical Syllogisms | |
| Accident | A generalization is applied when circumstances suggest that there should be an exception. |
| Converse Accident | An exception is applied in circumstances where a generalization should apply. |
| F. Causal Fallacies | |
| Post Hoc | Because one thing follows another, it is held to be caused by the other. |
| Joint effect | One thing is held to cause another when in fact they are both the joint effects of an underlying cause. |
| Insignificant | One thing is held to cause another, and it does, but it is insignificant compared to other causes of the effect. |
| Wrong Direction | The direction between cause and effect is reversed. |
| Complex Cause | The cause identified is only a part of the entire cause of the effect. |
| G. Missing the Point | |
| Begging the Question | The truth of the conclusion is assumed by the premises. |
| Irrelevant Conclusion | An argument in defense of one conclusion instead proves a different conclusion. |
| Straw Man | The author attacks an argument different from (and weaker than) the opposition's best argument. |
| H. Fallacies of Ambiguity | |
| Equivocation | The same term is used with two different meanings. |
| Amphiboly | The structure of a sentence allows two different interpretations. |
| Accent | The emphasis on a word or phrase suggests a meaning contrary to what the sentence actually says. |
| I. Category Errors | |
| Composition | Because the attributes of the parts of a whole have a certain property, it is argued that the whole has that property. |
| Division | Because the whole has a certain property, it is argued that the parts have that property. |
| J. Non Sequitur | |
| Affirming the Consequent | Any argument of the form: If A then B, B, therefore A. |
| Denying the Antecedent | Any argument of the form: If A then B, Not A, thus Not B. |
| Inconsistency | Asserting that contrary or contradictory statements are both true. |
| K. Syllogistic Errors | |
| Fallacy of Four Terms | A syllogism has four terms. |
| Undistributed Middle | Two separate categories are said to be connected because they share a common property. |
| Illicit Major | The predicate of the conclusion talks about all of something, but the premises only mention some cases of the term in the predicate. |
| Illicit Minor | The subject of the conclusion talks about all of something, but the premises only mention some cases of the term in the subject. |
| Fallacy of Exclusive Premises | A syllogism has two negative premises. |
| False Premise | Drawing an affirmative conclusion from a false premise. |
| Unstated Premise | Unstated premise may be false. |
| Existential Fallacy | A particular conclusion is drawn from universal premises. |
| L. Fallacies of Explanation | |
| Subverted Support | The phenomenon being explained doesn't exist. |
| Nonsupport | Evidence for the phenomenon being explained is biased. |
| Untestability | The theory which explains cannot be tested. |
| Limited Scope | The theory which explains can only explain one thing. |
| Limited Depth | The theory which explains does not appeal to underlying causes. |
| M. Fallacies of Definition | |
| Explanation | The definition is an explanation instead of a definition.
A definition has 2 parts:
|
| Too Broad | The definition includes items which should not be included. |
| Universal | The 'definition' is so broad that it becomes vague. |
| Too Narrow | The definition does not include all the items which should be included. |
| Failure to Elucidate | The definition is more difficult to understand than the word or concept being defined. |
| Circular Definition | The definition includes the term being defined as a part of the definition. |
| Conflicting Conditions | The definition is self-contradictory. |
| N. Broken-Chain Fallacy | |
| Omits part of argument | The speaker argues that:
A ⇒ B ⇒ C ⇒ D and then proves A ⇒ B, C ⇒ D but does not prove B ⇒ C. Example: the book The Reformation which purports to prove that the Reformation was a religious revolt when it was driven instead by mostly economic and political motives. |