>>

<<

 

8. Israelites worship … God who ?

Priests do not willingly share wealth and power.
The freedom-of-religion law does not protect freedom of religion.
It protects religions which oppose democracy, and kill non-believers.

The freedom-of-religion law protects the evils of religion.

The El pantheon was worshiped throughout Mesopotamia, the Fertile Crescent, Greece and Rome to Spain, with name changes. El or Zeus or eventually El-lah/Al-lah in Islam, was the father of all gods; Asherah was his consort, Astarte the goddess of love and fertility was the most important daughter, with Ba'al the god of storm and life-giving rain, his main son. There were over 70 other offspring. They were worshiped for thousands of years, as excavations at the Ugaritic Ras Shamra site attest. The Canaanites shared that same culture, and the Hapiru adopted it in either Canaan or earlier in Mesopotamia. The Bible suggests that during their migrations, they carried their idol of El, a gold bull-calf, in a box slung between two poles.

The creation of Yhwh occurred too late to fit into this international pantheon. Each god was owned by a powerful family, too powerful to try muscling in, so the Levites looked around, saw that the most popular god was Ba'al of the Covenant so they modelled their new god on Ba'al, changed his name to Yhwh of the Covenant, dropped his Storm God epithet, and instead made him a God of Everything.

Yhwh remained a local creation with only a local audience; neither a god of rain nor a god of fertility; neither a pastoral god nor a farming god; just a god of nothing – so He was driven to work, not by benefiting people, not by being loved, but by threatening them with war, pestilence and famine, and being feared. Yhwh introduced not the Religions of the Book but Religions of Fear.

08.07 Paganism before Yahwism

Israel was also called Ephraim and Samaria. Since the Israelites of Ephraim were exiled in 722bc, and those of Judea were exiled in 587bc, 70ce and 132ce, there was no impressive Jewish culture. The culture was 'introspective', concerned with religious taboos, rituals and superstitions which negated real education, philosophy, art, spirituality, science, discovery, exploration. 1

The Yahwist sects still look backward to an imaginary golden age under David and Solomon, conveniently forgetting that both kings were pagans worshiping El, and never Yhwh.
The sad story is that Jews still believe their own propaganda, intending to follow their god's command to conquer Palestine and Lebanon, and kill all non-Jewish inhabitants. About 1948, their terrorism was surprisingly successful but their current rate of kill has dropped, so now they clear the streets with sticky-napalm bombs,  2 enabling children to go home to die.

  1. This does not apply to modernised Jews, who are renown for their cultural contributions. However, their failure to follow the Law of Moses has banished them from Yhwh's presence, so they are recognized by traditional Jews as heretics, not real Jews. Ex:23.15; 29.28,38,42; 35.2-3; Lev 4.1,27-35; 19.27; 20.10,13; Num 15.30-41. The few faithful Jews, recognised by their dress, hair and beards, inbreeding and bigotry, remain as backward as ever. See heading “Immorality today,” end of ch Immorality.
  2. Gen 15.18; 17.8; Ex 23.30-3; Num 33.52; Deut 1.7,21; 3.3,6; 7.2, 22-4; 11.24; 1Kings 4.

08.08 The beginning

In the beginning there were many gods. The generic term for god was El, but El was the father of all gods, just as we use god and God in our speech. 1 His son Ba'al the Storm God and bringer of much-needed rain, became the most popular and enduring of the gods, against whom I-am could never compete. Even King David named two sons after Ba'al.

In the Hebrew Bible several different terms for god, which could therefore be different gods, are translated as God or Lord or I-am, or Jehovah. Thus the translations hide differences and contradictions. The Bible tries to show that I-am was the only god, but refers to other gods as though they exist. 2 If the Egyptian gods had not existed, then why the Passover, that slaughtering of thousands of children ?

The first recorded mentions of I-am occurred in 830 and 800bc, more than a century after David. In some places, especially in Psalm 29, I-am is a storm god, characteristic of El's son Ba'al but not El himself. Furthermore it is I-am who fights Leviathan in Isaiah 27.1; Psalm 74.14; Job 3.8 & Job 40.25-41.1, a deed attributed both to Ba'al/Hadad and 'Anat in the Ugarit texts, but not to Ēl. Thus in these passages the new god I-am was simply Ba'al renamed.

In the English Bible El is translated as God. Elohim is the plural form of El, as in 'Gods' but that indicates polytheism, so is translated as the singular 'God', to hide its polytheistic origins.

In the Levantine religion as a whole, including Canaanite religion, El is:

From 2000 to 1000bc, the Canaanites and the Hapiru, including the Israelites, worshiped El, his consort Asherah, and their offspring, Ba'al, Astarte, and 70 more, collectively called 'Elohim'. This is proven by the masses of bronze and terra cotta figurines at 'Israel' sites depicting Canaanite gods and goddesses.

The Bible says pagan gods included Astarte of Sidon, Chemosh of Moab, Molech of Ammon, Ba'al, Asherah, Dagon of Ashdod, Nisroch of Assyria, Rimmon of Syria, Succoth Benoth of Babylon, Nergal of Cuth, Ashima of Hamath, Nibhaz and Tartak of Ivvah, Adrammelech and Anammelech of Sepharvaim, Milcom of the Ammonites, Topheth and the Sun, Moon and stars. 4
However the Bible then tells us again and again that these gods were worshiped everywhere, even in the Temple of Jerusalem. 5

There would have been many more gods, not mentioned, because the people also had their household and agricultural gods, to whom they made offerings in the house and on the farm as well as at hill-top shrines. 6

The Bible avoids mentioning the parent of those pagan gods, the god El, because in the Book of Exodus, El's name was changed to I-am-WHO-IS-I-am, by the Zadokite priests in Jerusalem, probably after 716. The word Yhwh transliterates I-am. A better translation might be I-am-(who caused)-WHAT-IS, which means I-am-the-creator. 7 Ironically I-am-WHAT-IS is a perfect fit for El in our chapter Genesis retold.

The term 'Jehovah' came in the 16th century, from Pope Leo X's confessor, Peter Galatin. No Bible society uses the correct name I-am, but, being as pious as I am, I break with tradition and follow I-am's explicit instruction, given in Exodus 3.14-15.

  1. Gen 33.20.
  2. Deut 32.8-34 Song of Moses
  3. Psalms by David – for 'Lord' read 'El'; 2Chron 29.30 for Hezekiah; 34.3 for Josiah
  4. 1Kings 11.33; 2 King 1; 2Chron 33.3
  5. 2Kings 23.4-20
  6. 1Sam 9.13; 10.13; etc; 2Chron 21.11; 28.4; etc; 2Kings 17.10; Jer 17.2.
  7. Ex 3.14; M&C p334 para 1.

08.09 Biblical references to El

References to El in Genesis, Exodus, Numbers, and numerous Psalms include:

  1. El-Elohim (El-in Assembly of El) 1
  2. El-Shaddai (El-Unconquerable Power) 2
  3. El-Beth-El (El-House of El) 3
  4. El-Elyon (El-Most High, El's heavenly location) 4
  5. El-Elohe (El-God of Israel) 5
  6. El-Olam (El-Everlasting) 6
  7. El-Berith (El-God of Covenant: might be Baal-Berith, a Canaanite God) 7
  8. Eloah 8
  9. Yahweh and El. 9

Some, if not all, would have been used originally for non-Israelite deities. Deut's Song of Moses, ch 32, is revealing in that it keeps referring to the other Gods.

  1. Psalm 82.1
  2. Genesis 49.24; Numbers 22.5; 24.16; Psalm 91.1
  3. Genesis 28.18-19
  4. Gen 14.18-22; Deut 32.8-9; Psalm 18.13; 21.7; 47.2; 107.11
  5. Genesis 33.20 at Shechem, a Hapiru stronghold 33km north of Jerusalem.
  6. Genesis 21.33
  7. Judges 9.46; 8.33; 9.4
  8. Job
  9. Exodus 3.13-15; Psalm 29.1; 89.6

The most informative is Deuteronomy 32.8-9, the Song of Moses: When Elyon assigned nations their lands, He decided where people should live, and gave each their own god; but Yahweh chose the descendants of Jacob.Who had the worse deal - Yahweh or the Jews ? Note the use of Elyon instead of Yhwh in this Book of Deuteronomy even though Deuteronomy was first written as late as c.621bc.

Names: El is part of several important names in the Bible such as:

The Israelites, a sect of Hapiru, carried their El in their Ark, a small box carried on two poles through rings attached to the box. Although the Bible avoids admitting this, the Ark probably contained a gold or gold-plated bull-calf, the idol representing El:

  1. Ex 32.4
  2. Ex 32.4
  3. 1Kings 12.28,29,32-33; 2Chron 11.15
  4. 2Chron 29.30 Hezekiah sang David's psalms (to El). In 2Chron 34.3 Josiah worshiped the God of David, which was El. 34.32 says the people of Jerusalem, not the people of Judea, renewed the covenant. Then 34.33 tells how the king forced the Judeans to worship this God; they did so only under duress. 35.3 states that Josiah put the Ark of the Covenant into the Temple, in contradiction of 1Kings 8. Why ?

08.10 Asherah or Yahweh ?

[From Wikipedia "William G. Dever," 9 July 2012.] Dever used his extensive background in Near Eastern field archaeology to argue, in "Did God Have a Wife?" Archaeology and Folk Religion in Ancient Israel (2005), for the persistence of the veneration of Asherah in the everyday religion of 'ordinary people' in ancient Israel and Judea. Discussing extensive archaeological evidence from a range of Israelite sites, largely dated between the 12th and the 8th centuries bc, Dever argued that this 'folk' religion, with its local altars and cultic objects, amulets and votive offerings, was representative of the outlook of the majority of the population, and that the Jerusalem-centred 'book religion' of the Deuteronomist circle set out in the Hebrew Bible was only ever the preserve of an elite.

Or a god-scam. And the Hebrew Bible agrees, again and again. Judaic monotheism was for the religious and political elite:

Judaism was a god-scam, a cynical manipulation of the previous Canaan faith of 'hilltop shrines and shady trees', by the greedy parasitic Zadokite clan. Unfortunately it laid the basis for later more widely accepted god-scams that destroyed the pagan faiths, plunging the world into 2000 years of ignorance and misery from which we have yet to break free.

Superstition still rules legislation in the houses of parliament. What US president would dare say he was not a Christian ? US president George Bush declared that atheists were not fit to be citizens of the US. [interview, Dawkins] What happened to freedom of religion ?

08.11 Early worship

The two purposes of the Torah were:

This was to keep the Zadokite clan fat and wealthy. But the clan repeatedly outgrew its revenue, always chasing more by using its prophets from Isaiah, down to Malachi:
I am the Lord … is it right for a person to cheat God ? Of course not, yet you are cheating me … in the matter of tithes and offerings. A curse is on all of you because the whole nation is cheating me. Bring the full amount of your tithes to the Temple … (and) I will … pour out on you an abundance of all good things. I will not let insects eat your crops, and your grapevines will be loaded with grapes. Then people of all nations will call you happy. [Malachi 3.6-12]

How obvious can a god-scam be ? Who was I-am ? Based on fear of war, pestilence and famine, God I-am was a superstition to scare people into giving livestock, crops and money to the Zadokite priests.

08.12 El or I-am ?

Yahwism was the Canaanite religion of El, captured and corrupted by the Zadokite priests to make it uniquely theirs. Compare like-numbers to see why the people preferred paganism.

Pagan-godI-am (Yhwh)
  1. Name of 'El', joyfully used in names like Dani-EL, Samu-EL, Isra-EL, Beth-EL
  2. Worshiped joyously in natural sites.
  3. Voluntary sacrifice; worshippers give when & what they can afford.
  4. Gods respond to personal worship.
  5. Freedom of religion.
  6. Few or no priests; surplus produce re-invested in more agriculture and pastoralism, or saved for droughts.
  7. Gods smile on worshippers.
  8. Gods never punish the innocent.
  9. Evil is done by Jinns, not Gods.
  10. Late paganism (priests) might combine kingship and priesthood. 3
  1. God's name, Yhwh too sacred to mention; God is the God-to-be-Feared.
  2. Worshipped in Temple's inner sanctum.
  3. People forced to pay excessive sacrifices but denied access to shrine/altar and ritual.
  4. Priests were corrupt 1
  5. Worship Yhwh or be stoned to death.
  6. Huge cast of priests and assistants, with king's military backing, parasitize poor agricultural society.
  7. Authoritarian regime of priests; rigid Law; harsh punishments.
  8. God destroys innocents for guilt of others. God ignores immorality.
  9. God is jealous, vengeful. Causes all evil. 2
  10. Kingship and priesthood were separate.
Pagan-godI-am (Yhwh)
  1. God of location; each village its own El; each god worshiped on his own soil.
  2. God is worshipped at hill-top shrines.
  3. Abraham brought teraphim El from Mesopotamia.
  4. Pagan polytheism; Canaanite & Mesop. 4
  5. Prophesy by dreams, signs.
  6. No circumcision.
  7. Food - can eat everything.
  8. Clothing - identifies tribe.
  9. Codified law from Mesopotamia
  10. Sacrifices - voluntary
  11. Human sacrifice - not before priests arose. 5
  1. God of the chosen people.
  2. God sits on His Ark, hidden in Temple.
  3. No idols; Menorah used instead.
  4. Henotheism then monotheism but failed.
  5. Prophesy by Urim & Thummim or dreams
  6. Circumcision.
  7. Food - only cosher.
  8. Clothing - identifies religion.
  9. Law (of Moses), mostly for revenue.
  10. Sacrifices by coercion, causing debt.
  11. Human sacrifice:

    • on a mass scale  6
    • of individuals  7

If you were not already biased by worshipping I-am, which God would you prefer to worship ?

  1. Samuel's sons; Eli's sons; 2Kings 12.4-8; 2Chron 29.3-7,34; 30.1,15; protests by prophets Amos & Hosea; Hellenized Sadducees; etc.
  2. Isa 45.7; Amos 3.6; Lev 26; Deut 28.
  3. Gen 14.18; Judges
  4. Gen 31.17-19; 35.2,10; Jos 24.14
  5. 2Kings 16.3; 23.10
  6. Passover; Deut 13.16; Joshua's genocides; Judges 11.30-40; 2Sam 21.1-14; 24.14-16
  7. Lev 27.28-9; Judges 11.30-40; 2Kings 16.3.

08.13 I-am justice

Samaria must be punished for rebelling against me. Her people will die in war; babies will be dashed to the ground; and pregnant women will be ripped open. 1 Babies, guilty of not worshipping I-am, will be dashed to the ground. And when you go to church, you give money to propagate this Monster … aren't you ashamed ?

Jews and Christians believe I-am stands for justice. This is an example of people looking at the Bible instead of reading it. Or of reading what they think it says instead of what it really says. If they read the Bible, instead of merely looking at it, they would read that I-am caused:

Furthermore, I-am hates freedom of religion, homosexuals, blind, lame, crippled, deformed, hunchback, dwarf, those with any eye or skin disease, eunuch, Samaritans, pagans, apostates, the original Palestinian inhabitants, non-virgins **, and virtually anyone who does not conform to the clan's demands for revenue or believe its lies. 6 This bigotry poisons our society still.

** A girl who, on marrying, cannot prove herself to have been a virgin, is to be killed. The onus of proof, after having had sex with her new husband, is upon her. Presumably she must show blood on the sheet, which is not always possible. Barbaric. 7 In Num, God ordered that when towns were taken, non-virgins were to be killed. 8
Why are priests so obsessed with sex as to warp their judgment ? In what manner does the rupture of a hymen render a woman a social outcast, with sufficient reason to kill her ? And the genital mutilation of babies, boys in Judaism, girls in Islam. What is it about Abrahamic religions that produces such sick and twisted minds ?

Paganism has none of these problems.
I-am has a peculiar sense of justice. Do you sense a hint of hypocrisy in I-am's words: But if a man be just, and do that which is lawful and right … he shall surely live. If he has a son that is a robber, a shedder of blood, and that does the like to any one of these things … he (the son) shall surely die; his blood shall be upon him …. [Ezekiel 18.5, etc.] As God explained in Ezekiel, only the sinner will be punished for their own sins and not for the sins of others. Nor will others be punished for sins they did not commit. And yet:

Someone should warn I-am, hypocrisy should never be put in writing.

This is the religion which is forced upon our children in church schools. How warped were the minds of priests that they could create such a monster, and call him God.The Gnostics believe that I-am is the Evil Demiurge against whom the True God must wage perpetual war. And we are caught in the middle … . Note the book's main message: I am going to punish Jerusalem … They have rejected me and offered sacrifices to other gods … . This god of the Zadokites recognizes the existence of other gods, but objects to sacrifices going to their shrines …Judges 2.13-14. They stopped worshipping I-am and served the Baals and the Astartes. And so I-am became furious with Israel and let the raiders attack and rob them. And kill them.
These threats occur in every chapter, over and over again, along with many contradictions, injustices and punishment of innocents. There is no Hell with which to threaten them; Hell will not be incorporated from Zoroastrianism by the Pharisees, till about 200bc; so punishment had to be in this life. And when it was not, the Sadducees had to invent it. And every reverse event, every war, pestilence and famine, of which there were many, was blamed on I-am's anger at their infidelity. The whole Testament is about frightening people into directing all religious revenue to the Temple of Jerusalem, and justifying that threat with The Law of Mythical Moses…. A god-scam … an evil god-scam … an I-am scam.

  1. Hosea 13.16
  2. Ex 12.12; Num 33.4.
  3. Deut 3.6; 20.16; Joshua 6.21; 8.2,22,25-26; 9.24; 10.30,40; 11.11,14,20.
  4. 2Samuel 24.1,10,15 contradicted by 1Chron 21.1.
  5. 2Kings 5.1; 13.3; 15.27-29, 34-37; 17.1-12, 18-20.
  6. Lev 18.22; 20.13; 21.16-23; Deut 2.34; 3.3,6; 20.16; 22.13-21; 23.1-2
  7. Lev 21.16-23; Deut 22.20
  8. Num 30.17,32-35,42-46
  9. Num 31.17
  10. Num 14.18; 1Kings 14.12-13; 15.29-30
  11. Deut 23.2
  12. 1Kings 14.22-26; 15.9-24; 2Kings 21.10-15; 23.26-27 contradicting 2Chron 33.10-17
  13. 2Chron for David, Ahaz, Hezekiah, Manessah, …

08.14 Why did I-am fail ?

The religion was originally polytheistic and, in spite of repeated attempts to control revenue by imposing henotheism and then monotheism, the public and even the priests within the Temple of Jerusalem, remained polytheistic. 1
The big question is, why ? Why was I-am so inadequate; why were Ba'al, Astarte and Asherah so appealing ? Was I-am too vague; by being god of everything, was he god of nothing ? Ba'al was specific, a god of storm and rain, and he lived on the hill next to my farm, bringing rain each winter, but I-am lived away in the Temple of Jerusalem supposedly protecting Judea but doing it badly. He was pathetic at stopping invasions.
While Ba'al did not ask for much in sacrifices, only as much as we could spare, I-am asked so much we often went hungry. The priests demanded sacrifices for fellowship offerings, sin-offerings, repayment offerings, grain offerings, wine offerings; each month, each harvest, for the slightest sin, having sex, menstruating, childbirth; skin-diseases, illness, mildew on clothing or walls; festival days; you name it, the priests taxed it. They even knew when my wife became pregnant, before I knew, because they noted when she missed her post-menstrual offering.
They took our best livestock, when we needed to breed from them. They took so much we went into debt and lost our land, becoming landless laborers and slaves. And where did the sacrifices go ? Into the bellies of fat priests. And on top of that, we paid tithes that bought fancy clothes and high living in luxurious houses, for those same fat priests … while my children starved. 2
Thus the priests, by demanding too much, with brutal force, alienated the population. Their corruption made it worse. But the question remains, why did the priests not believe their own propaganda; why did they have idols for Ba'al, Astarte and Asherah in their Temple of Jerusalem, up till its destruction in 70ce ? 3 Why was god I-am never enough ?
God I-am is a god of arrogance, jealousy, anger, hate, vengeance and death; collectively punishing the innocent for the sins of the guilty. Fidelity is irrelevant - the innocent are punished while the guilty go unscathed. I-am has hated for so long he does not know how to love. Indiscriminately I-am brings war, pestilence and famine while Ba'al brings rain to parched soil, Astarte brings love and fertility. Which god deserves our worship ?
People need to feel in control of their lives. They need to see good behaviour rewarded; bad behaviour punished. Calamities must have explanations other than a god's capriciousness. Jews still celebrate the Passover, the slaughter of innocents. When, as a teenager, I read Job and saw him manipulated and betrayed, and his children killed, for no reason but I-am's perverse preening of pride, I knew I-am is evil. I declared war against evil.
Why do we, in our modern societies, tolerate these cruel religions based on fear ? Religions which feed on the timid, the ignorant, the weak ? Sucking meagre savings into overflowing coffers ? Religions which openly oppose freedom of religion with death ? Evil religions protected by laws of religious freedom ?

  1. Ex 32.4-5 declares God El brought them out of Egypt; Num 25.5,9; 1Kings 2.35;
    Deut 32.8,31 God says, … their own gods are weak, not mighty like me, Israel's God; - God Yhwh does not know he was never Israel's God; God El was; but Kings David and Jeroboam I have yet to tell him. Even King Hezekiah in 716bc, worshipped, not Yhwh, but David's El. 1Kings 12.28-31 declares God El brought them out of Egypt; 2Kings 23.4-20; 1Chron 6.1-53; and endless examples later. Luke in Acts 7.39-45, has Stephen saying Molech brought them out of Egypt.
  2. Proverbs 31.6-9; 29.14; Psalms 72.2,4,12-14; See prophets Isa 10.1-2; 58.3-10; Amos 2.6-8; 4.1; Eze 18.
  3. 2Kings 23.4-20.

 

>>

<<