This chapter appears to be repetitive, but each repetition encompasses more arguments and extends the conclusions. Without the repetitions, the arguments do not glue together to prove the conclusions.
Judaic
God: Kill anyone who offers sacrifices to any god but
me. 1
Priests
have killed those who question their false dogma. Moslems still do.
We
must oppose every religion which denies our religious freedom and our democracy.
The
purpose of religious schools is not to educate but to isolate and indoctrinate with superstition and
fear of hell. Give me the boy for seven years and I will give you back the man. Jesuit priest.
The
child cannot have religious freedom in a religious school.
One portion of the Habiru settled in the hills of Ephraim, and in their isolation evolved a modified culture whose most notable characteristic was its genital mutilation of males. (Moslems prefer genital mutilation of females.)
About 930bc, the Israelites evicted the priestly Levite caste and
their followers, who fled to Jerusalem, taking their Yhwh of Shechem to Jerusalem ? Having witnessed the popularity of Ba'al-of-the-Covenant in Israel, the Levites plagiarized this intellectual property and called their god, Yhwh-of-the-Covenant but the local Judeans referred to Him by His origins, as Yhwh of the Israelites. This evolved into the story of the Israelites making a covenant with Yhwh, a story that was to embarrass the Levites since the Israelites always scorned Yhwh. Fortunately the Israelites disappeared from history in 722bc. The Judeans wanted to scorn Him but the priests after 536bc developed too much power. When Pharaoh Shishek sacked Jerusalem in 924, taking El's gold bull-calf and his priests to Egypt, the Levites seized the opportunity to install their Yhwh-of-the-Covenant-with-the-Israelites as chief god in the main Temple.
Meanwhile the Israelites continued
worshiping El, 1
but in 722bc most Israelites were forcibly removed to Assyria, while
others fled to Egypt. The poor who remained, along with immigrants
from Assyria, became known as Samarians, after their capital
Samaria. They remained pagan. Thus, according to the Hebrew Bible,
the Israelites worshiped El and Ba'al but never Yhwh. 2
The earliest archaeological record of Yhwh was Yhwh of Samaria, appearing in 830bc with a wife Asherah, at a shrine on the way to Egypt. This Yhwh of Samaria was chosen specifically for the city of Samaria, since each god had his own location such as El of Bethel and El of Dan – like mascots with power – but Samaria was built by King Omri ruling 885-874, so this Yhwh of Samaria was a recent God in Israel, no earlier than 880bc, in addition to and distinct from Yhwh of Jerusalem. This was illustrated when the Hasmonean dynasty, devotees to the Yhwh of Jerusalem, sacked the Temple of Yhwh of Samaria, c.140bc.
After the High Priest Hilkiah produced Deuteronomy 1st Edition in 621bc, the Judeans were marched off to Babylon, inspiring the Deuteronomists to finish the Pentateuch and to write the Deuteronomic Histories, Books Joshua to 2Kings, during the Exile of 587 - 536bc.
Both Hezekiah (716–687bc) and Josiah (640-609bc), used David's psalms to worship El, 3 so the main sect in Jerusalem, having royal patronage, was the El sect, not the Yhwh sect. However, throughout the Scriptures, the Ba'al and Astarte sects, were recorded as being the most popular with the public.
When the Deuteronomists returned after the Exile of 587–536bc with money to rebuild the Temple, they claimed ownership of this new Temple and excluded all but Yhwh of the Covenant, but ran short of money.
Those Levites, descended from the Israelites, and the Aaronites descended within the Levite clan, and the Zadokites within the Aaronite clan, struggled against each other to claim the lucrative High Priesthood and its nespotic privileges, but it was the Zadokite Chroniclers, returning under Ezra with buckets of gold from Persia to finish building the Temple, that paid their acceptance into the elite of Jerusalem. In that poverty stricken country, their sect had the prestige that money could buy, and the authority granted by the Persian emperor.
Owning the new Temple, the Zadokites established the Sanhedrin, the High Court, that kept the powerful in power. Religion is self-perpetuating. It was not until 70ce that the Romans demolished the Temple, and with it, priestly power. But then the people transferred that power to the emerging rabbi. Even religion is recycled. And stupidity too.
When the Zadokite priests rewrote their scriptures with the name and story of Yhwh of the Covenant, they forgot to change the name in the psalms dedicated to El and
Ba'al. Why did they change the name ? El was worshiped from Ur near the mouth of the Euphrates, up to Haran and down to Jerusalem, with every town having its own Temple of El. Why would citizens of Bethel bring sacrifices to El of Jerusalem when they could more easily offer them to El of Bethel ?
To create a monopoly over sacrifices the Levite priests in Israel needed a unique god, so they had morphed El into Yhwh, copied the most-popular god, Ba'al of the Covenant, by making Yhwh of the Covenant, and made him unique by circumcision, by a covenant, by blaming every war, every pestilence, every famine on his jealous retribution for failure to bring all sacrifices to the 'one place of worship', namely their Temple of Jerusalem. To broaden the scope of sacrifices they made their Yhwh god of rain, god of fertility, god of crops, god of everything; but in making him god of everything they made him god of nothing.
By making Yhwh a tribal god obsessed with
punishing his tribe's polytheism with war, pestilence and famine, the Levites made Yhwh a god of war, pestilence and famine, a morbid jealous god. Which partly explains why Yhwh was never popular.
Yhwh boasted sending all invasions, and deciding their outcomes. 4 That would include all devastations, from Shishak in 924bc to Hitler in 1933-44ce. That poor Hitler was an unwitting slave to Yhwh's jealous retribution, is not happily appreciated by Yhwh's chosen people. While Jews avoid admitting this punishment for their infidelity, their Hebrew Scriptures, their inerrant Word of God, is adamant. 5 The Jews are damned by their own Scriptures.
Judaic dogma was compiled mostly in the 6th to 4th centuries bc but not redacted into the Hebrew Bible till 70-120ce. Archeological evidence overwhelmingly refutes the Pentateuch, thus revealing the Passover, Exodus, Moses, the invasion of Canaan by the Israelites, and the wealth of Solomon, to be mythology, concocted mostly during the Exile in Babylon during 587-536bc. The existence of David and Solomon is arguable. So far, no-one has evidence of the first Temple of Jerusalem, although the size given in the Scriptures is so small, and it lacked a roof, so it might have been possible with Solomon's limited wealth. The authorship and dating of the various books are hotly debated, challenging the main argument for the existence of divine authority, namely the divine inspiration of prophecies, 'prophecies' which turn out to be prophecies-by-hindsight or false. Even God's prophecies are false.
Believers tend to justify the contradictions, inconsistencies and mistakes in the scriptures by:
I hope that they read this book to help them read the Hebrew Scriptures intelligently, and reject priestly lies and prejudices and manipulations; and to instead base their faith on the Scriptures REAL message, namely, compassion - treating others as oneself; and through compassion to develop a moral tolerant and inclusive faith. While people resort to religion in times of stress, often those stressful times are the result of religious prejudices and bigotry. For 2000 years, and on into the 21st century, most wars and most attempted genocides, although often motivated by greed, have been precipitated by politicians and priests manipulating religious bigotry.
The Ark of the Israelites, the box for carrying the gold bull-calf idol for their god El, previously guarded at Shiloh, had been left at Abinadab's farm, rejected by both Levites and Aaronites because its captors, the Philistines, had contracted the bubonic plague. David out-manoeuvred them by stealing their God El with the Ark. While doing so, David danced like a prophet or like a shaman, as Samuel and Saul had done.
Query: Since David was a Moabite-cum-Judean while the Levites were Israelite, why would they dominate in service to David and Solomon ? Were they the only literate class ? Or was this a re-writing of history ? After all, the Chroniclers wrote their ancestor Zadok into the scriptures some 600 years after the event supposedly occurred. Since they wrote and guarded the Scriptures, no-one could contradict them. When did the Levites, a clan within the Israelites, take over the Temple of Jerusalem ? Was it after 924bc, when the Pharaoh Shishek sacked Jerusalem,removing El's idols and His priests ? after 536bc when the returning Deuteronomists began rebuilding the Temple with Persian money ? after 457bc when the returning Chroniclers finished rebuilding the Temple with Persian money ?
Deut demands endlessly that all sacrifices must go to the Temple of Jerusalem but that was impossible. The Israelites would never have carried all their sacrifices, all the different offerings, walking from Ephraim to the Temple of Jerusalem and back, some 34 km with a sheep, repeatedly through the week and still run a farm. No, this is unbelievable. This could not have been written by Moses, but only after the Israelites had ended the alliance and when only the Judeans could be coerced into taking sacrifices to Jerusalem. It would more likely to have been 621bc when Hilkiah gave Deut to Josiah, and Josiah destroyed outside shrines.
Earlier, immediately after the Assyrian removal of the Israelites from history in 722, Hezekiah needed Temple coffers full to pay the Assyrian invaders to
leave, so he rejuvenated the Temple, priests and services, and
inspired the priests to begin writing a new mythology to win
popular approval to increase revenue. The written word, living magic
in an illiterate society, was to be persuasive down through 2700
years. After all, you believe the Scriptures, don't you ?
In 621, King Josiah destroyed all shrines outside of Jerusalem, in the same year that High Priest Hilkiah produced from nowhere the Book of Deuteronomy in which was proclaimed God's call to make sacrifices at only 'the one place of worship'. Josiah was inspired by the written word, but it also suited his political ambitions of continuing Hezekiah's policy of centralising control.
Jewish and Christian writers pretend that El and His many forms were other terms for Yhwh, and that therefore Yhwhism was monotheistic. This is map-bending, that is, bending the facts to fit their beliefs instead of changing their beliefs to fit the facts. Yhwh Himself, recognized other gods. Yhwh boasted that the Passover was to show the Egyptian gods that he was more powerful. Yhwh talked of other gods as competitors but declared that His chosen people must not worship them. He is very jealous of Ba'al, Astarte and Asherah. [Judges 3.7-8 etc]
El was the early or
original Ugaritic God of the Semites, 1 and the Levite Yhwh was a much later invention to grab religious revenue. This was done by copying the features of both El and Ba'al, especially of Ba'al of the Covenant. 2 How blatant a theft of intellectual property !? When was Yhwh created by the Levites ?
Some ideas which help are:
David worshiped El:
Otherwise the Gods El and Yhwh were worshiped in parallel until the return of the bigoted Deuteronomists in 536, and especially the Prophet Ezra in 458bc. They then claimed the new Temple as their private domain, evicting El with a selfishness and bigotry unheard of in the past in which the community Temple was held in common.
This story can be gleaned from Kings and Chronicles. Let
us imagine these periods:
Thus my conclusion is that, while the early songs or psalms belong to
an early period of pagan worship of El, Asherah, Ba'al
and Astarte, the Pentateuch was begun in 716–621bc,
Deuteronomy was compiled from its notes in 621, and serious work and
the push for Yhwh was done by the frightened Exiles
after 587. Lethargy returned after the stress of the Exile ended, and the Deuteronomists were distracted by temple building and the corruption of Persian money, from 536
onwards, so the Scriptural work was not completed till about 458 by the
Chroniclers for their return to Jerusalem.
This dating, based on the Bible story, assumes the Scriptures are
reliable - a risky assumption.
See also chapter Bible concepts, heading Pentateuch. The Hebrew Bible is biased political history with mythical explanations:
Deuteronomic Histories
DH was written by a single group and then compiled by a single author, in the time of King Josiah (640-609bc). High Priest Hilkiah gave his edition of the single book Deuteronomy to Josiah in 621bc, 3 but the final edition of Deuteronomic Histories [DH] was authored during the Babylonian exile, 587-536bc. The Book of Deuteronomy was then shifted to the Pentateuch (Greek for '5 Books'). DH is a hypothetical collection of:
Chronicles of 458bc plagiarizes Kings, giving the pro-Zadokite view of the 2nd batch of returnees, called Chroniclers, rivals to the Deuteronomists. Their three main aims were:
The Zadokites wrote not a whole book, but the parts that were important at the time. They patched the holes over several centuries by adding distorted versions of history to justify their demands. God had nothing to do with it. It was a revenue-driven god-scam for and by greedy priests.
Note in the Pentateuch, the mythologized struggle as the commoners fought for religious freedom, but lost to the violence and treachery of the priests. 7
Finally, 1Kings 13.1-3, prophesying King Josiah 300 years onwards, an unusually precise prophesy typical of prophecy-by-hindsight, dates this book as post-620bc.
Consists of:
The Hebrew Bible or Old Testament: all 900 confusing pages, is a dishonest manipulation of the history of Judea and Ephraim (Israel) to verify The Message, in order to scare people into maximizing their contributions to the Zadokite god-scam.
The
Hebrew Bible is that simple. The evil I-am is a recent
invention, a Zadokite god-scam, and not the true God El with
his consort Asherah, that we have known for 10,000 years . . .
. .
. you can now return to the true faith . . .