This Ark of God was a wooden box, 1.10 long x 0.66 wide x 0.68m high, which carried the Covenant or contract between God and his chosen people, summarised as the 10 Commandments, on the 2 stone tablets engraved by God I-am. This God I-am sat on the Ark while amongst his chosen people 1 Or did He ? Can you unravel the many secrets of the Ark ? 2 Why would they make a box instead of a throne ? The box was used by Hapiru to carry their idols, in this case a gold bull-calf dedicated to El. Christians say pagans worship idols. In that case, Christians worship the idols in every cathedral, particularly Christ-on-a-Cross, and kitsch Mary installed offensively and aggressively over every pagan shrine, and idols of saints, not to mention the crucifix over the bed – a religious indulgence for Christian exhibitionists.
Canaan was the Levant, the east end of the Mediterranean, from Gaza to Aleppo, but shrank as other peoples made inroads from the coast and from the Euphrates River basin. For our story, Canaan is the land from the Jordan River west to the coastal states of Phoenicia (towns Tyre, Sidon, Byblos) and Philistia (towns Gaza, Ashkelon, Ashdod). The most important players are all hill countries - Judea in the south, with Benjamin on its northern boundary, then Ephraim running north to the Habiru fortified town of Shechem. Ephraim was called 'Israel' by the Zadokites. It expanded and shrank as it won and lost territories, but with Assyrian conquest was renamed Samaria after its capital built by King Omri c.880bc.
From Dan in the north to Beersheba in the south is 270km, and from Philistia's town of Gath to the Dead Sea is 56km direct. In the middle, from the Ephraim coast to the Jordan River is 80km … a 16-hour walk across a tiny country in which everywhere is walking distance from everywhere. Most of it is barren hills, but has winter rains trapped in limestone, issuing forth from springs throughout the year, if they are lucky. The summer is hot and dry. Much of agriculture was and is on terraced slopes. Strangely, western books refer to this hill country as being fertile, but their authors have never terraced barren hills or planted trees in rock. The productivity of farms is proportional to the capital invested in terracing and planting, produced by thousands of years of blisters, tears and starvation.
Cosher: see Kosher.
God I-am declared himself to be the source of all good and all
evil. 1
The Bible openly shows I-am's actions are mostly evil
arising out of psychopathic jealousy of other gods, as in the the
Flood, Passover, genocide of Canaan towns, Assyrian and Babylonian
invasions, epidemics and famines. Surely, a god, to be a god, would
be above jealousy; a god would be a Cynic, accepting people as they
are, and not demanding that they pay tax to priests to feed His
arrogance.
I-am displays all the traits that are contemptible,
including demands for burnt offerings because the smell of burning
flesh turns him on, human sacrifice including genocide, senseless
slaughter of innocents including children, as well as traits of
uncontrolled anger (Uzzah), jealousy, pettiness and arrogance. In our
society such a person would be sentenced to life imprisonment.
President Saddam Hussein of Iraq was executed as a war criminal for
far less.
The Christian New Testament blames I-am's evil on
harmless Satan or some poor Devil. The priests blame Jerome's version of
Lucifer, the bringer of light (Venus), but God I-am's
promises and threats are listed clearly in Leviticus ch.26 and
Deuteronomy ch.28, when God spoke directly to his people. If you do
not believe these Words of God, what do you believe ? The Jewish god I-am is guilty by his own words:
Foreign invasions were all divine punishments for Judean infidelity in worshiping Canaanite gods. When Judeans repented, I-am relented, inspiring someone to be Judge, and through him rescuing Israel. The geographic, political and economic causes of invasions, war and betrayal, are ignored in the Hebrew Bible, so that priests could use these setbacks as threats demanding more sacrifices and tithes at their Temple of Jerusalem, I-am's 'one place of worship'. 1
Hapiru were not a blood-group but outlaws-in-the-Ephraim-hills;
initially refugees from Asia Minor and Mesopotamia, but supplemented
by drifters, pastoralists who lost their stock through drought,
farmers driven off their land, refugees from sacked towns or
criminals fleeing the law – eking out an existence in the
barren hills, but supplemented by raiding towns, villages, and farms
of the fertile valleys below, and taxing travelling traders. (This
custom continued in Arabia into Prophet Muhammed's time.)
Instead of 12 Tribes of Israel spread over the length of Palestine,
1Kings 11.35-6 says that 10 tribes lived in Ephraim alone, and one in
Judea, indicating that the one in Judea was outnumbered by the three other tribes there, the Jebusites, Amorites and Hittites. At best, Israelite culture in Jerusalem was a minority, so the Chronicles' attempt to call Judea 'Israel' is farcical. Those 10 tribes in Ephraim were each centered on a fortified town
surrounded by hundreds of extended-family homesteads. Over the
centuries, by inbreeding, they might have evolved into 12 tribes of
relatives.
As they built in numbers, weaponry and military experience, they
captured the valleys from the Canaanites and eventually defeated the
Philistines. Their stronghold was Shechem, a strategic town
dominating the valley between Mt Gerizim and Mt Ebal, which, after
900bc, by using camel trains across the desert, became the trade route from Mesopotamia to the Mediterranean,
Egypt, and Africa. At the time of Egypt's overlordship, the Hapiru
played the local warlords off against each other. The Law of Moses
seems to have evolved from the Sumerian or Hammurabi law brought by
the Hapiru.
Israel was a group of Hapiru towns in the hills of Ephraim, north of
Judea's town of Benjamin, and south of Mount Ebal in Western
Manasseh. Its main towns were Shechem, Shiloh, Timnath Serah, Bethel,
Ai, Shamir. The statement in Judges 20.1 All the people of Israel
from Dan in the north to Beersheba in the south is propaganda
contradicted by 1Kings 11.35-6. The term 'Israel' should be
restricted to Ephraim, which became identified by their developing
military prowess which enabled them to occupy the valleys. 1 The Bible says repeatedly, They came down from the hills of Ephraim. 2
The Israelites did not come from Egypt except, perhaps, some released hostages. Ephraim's (Israelite) towns were only briefly
allied to Judea (c.990 - 930bc) until the war against Philistia
ended, freeing them to fight each other.
The first external mention of Israel occurred in c.1207 when
Pharaoh Merneptah mentioned on his 'Israel' Stela that he had
defeated a townless tribe called 'Israel' in Canaan. The transition
from the Bronze Age to the Early Iron Age (1300-1200), of the Ephraim
tribes collectively called Israel, was a gradual transformation with
consistent Canaanite worship, continuous cultural evolution and absence of charcoal left by burning villages, all refuting the violence of the Bible's
Book of Joshua. Further, the HS Psalms to El seem to be copies
of Canaanite Psalms.
Instead of the Israelites, it was the Sea-Peoples that conquered Canaan. Instead of the Israelites, it was earthquakes that tumbled the walls of Jericho.
The evidence is in the excavations. The earthquake fissures wrecking the walls, disturbed a grave, which has been dated. The Zadokite authors fantasized themselves in the role
of the Sea-Peoples as conquerors of Canaan. Wishful thinking. The
gentle cultural transition in the hills indicates that worship by any
Israel tribe grew out of Canaanite religion before the arrival of the
Sea Peoples.
This similarity of gods, rituals and worship across
Canaanite and Judean cultures, compelled the 7th century
Zadokite priests to justify their claim for uniqueness by making
their god so threatening, and eventually, so evil. 3 Remember that Yahwism was the eventual religion of the Judeans, post-458bc, but never that of the Israelites. About 458bc, owning the second Temple, the Zadokites made their own god supreme in worship, with Yhwh displacing El.
They made Yhwh the source of all good and
evil, and used His jealousy to threaten polytheists with war,
pestilence and famine. Nonetheless their success was unimpressive.
The Bible tells us that their own Temple of Jerusalem, except for
three brief bursts, contained pagan idols for 1000 years.
We need to stop thinking of Israelites as descendants of
Jacob-Israel, and see them as members of Hapiru tribes sharing a
similar evolving culture. According to God, Ephraim, not Judea,
was Israel: (Jerobam I) I will make you king of Israel.
Jeroboam ruled Ephraim, while God gave Judea to Rehoboam. 4
The Bible says Israelites worshiped El of Bethel and El
of Dan, not I-am of Jerusalem:
It follows that Yhwh of Jerusalem was never accepted
by the Israelites. Anything to the contrary is Jewish propaganda.
If in doubt, read the Bible; after all, the ancient Jews wrote it.
With the Israelites gone in 722bc, the Chronicles of 458 called
'Israel' the 'northern state', and shifted the term 'Israel' to Judea,
to create the myth of Israelites worshiping Yhwh of
Jerusalem, no longer of Samaria. More Jewish propaganda.
Judea became Israelite only if the peoples of Jerusalem adopted
circumcision. Records indicate that the Zadokite/Sadducees in
Jerusalem were circumcised but the Hebrew Bible leaves Jerusalem's
majority population, the Jebusites, Amorites and Hittites,
uncircumcised. The majority of Jerusalemites remained pagan. 9
M&C's Map 5 shows Israel covering a larger area under the heading
'Kingdoms of Israel & Judea', but in view of:
the so-called 'Kingdom of Israel' was less a kingdom than a fragile
and brief 10th century transition between chaos and chaos, lasting
only 80 years and falling apart in 930bc. Kings were as changeable as the weather; most were assassinated. King
Shallum lasted only a month. Only today's Jewish propaganda pretends
that the state of Israel was ever more than a state of anarchy and
Canaanite paganism. If in doubt, read the Bible.
Under the Omri dynasty (885 - 841bc) Ephraim/Israel attained
affluence for the ruling class, and under Baasha (909-886), Jehu
(841-814) and Jeroboam II (783-743) saw long reigns, but apart from
two reigns of 15 years, the other nine, of 7 days, 1 and 6 months,
and then 1,1,1,5,5,9 years, were brief and bloody … hardly the
united nation of Israelites, pictured in Jewish propaganda.
Jerusalem was a village in 3rd millennium bc, with a defensive wall
c.1800bc; was prosperous c.1500 but went into decline for the 'Golden
Age' of David and Solomon, then improved under Omri and Ahab.
It perhaps had a population of 5000 under Solomon (930bc) and 25,000
under Hezekiah (700bc). 1
David was a Moabite Judean from Bethlehem, and wisely never trusted
the Ephraimites (Israelites), so he favored a capital in Judea,
firstly Hebron then Jerusalem, c.1000bc 2
because of these military advantages:
However, Jerusalem in Solomon's day was
probably no more than 5000 people, which is just a village crammed on
top of a hill. It would not have housed many soldiers or much
supplies. With Jerusalem being much smaller and less protected in
David's day, David fled from Absalom's superior numbers, rather than
be trapped on a hill, in a walled town or be betrayed by his many enemies within Jerusalem. From his lookout, David had had time
to escape with his forces and family. He chose to fight in the hilly
forest of Ephraim, a terrain of which he had become a military master
when fighting his predecessor King Saul. 4
Compare 1Sam 23.7-13.
Not economically advantaged like Shechem on the northern trade route
from the Jordan to the coast; nor having agricultural advantages of
the moist and fertile valleys and coastal plain, Jerusalem was
stimulated by becoming the religious and administrative center
of Judea. 5
We note that:
The scriptures falsely portrayed people demanding from I-am a
king to rule over them; that Saul, David and Solomon were chosen by
I-am personally; and that the people had voted to verify their
support. The Bible faked the 'divine right of kings' to win the
king's military support for the god-scam, but also recorded that the
Israelites under David's son, Absalom, withdrew support from David.
Very fickle.
Soon after Solomon died in 930bc, the Israelites
rebelled, and soon expelled the Levites, the literate recorders and probable taxmen of the displaced warlords. The Israelites must, at the same time, have rejected the god of the Levites, in favor
of the religious freedom of paganism, making a mockery of the
fictitious Exodus. 8
They would never have rejected a god whom their ancestors had seen
face-to-face. Would you ?
A Judge was a person elected to lead a tribe on specific military campaigns and then return home as a 'normal' citizen. By Samuel's time, c.1060bc, a Judge-ship was becoming hereditary. Combining prophet and magistrate indicated that the ability to be a prophet could be taught and learnt, like a trade with secret knowledge which we would call 'tricks', such as reading the Urim and Thummim to learn God's wishes. (Saul failed this test in 1Sam 28.6. Also paradoxically God forbade divination.)
The king was initially a warlord elected by the patriarchs of the
rural extended-family settlements, on a lifelong basis to govern a
tribe or tribes. Later the kingship was hereditary if he could hold
on to it. If not, it went to the person who killed the king, if he
could hold on to it.
The Bible says that the people demanded the rule of kings to overcome
the corruption of theocratic rule at that time. 1
However, although Samuel anointed Saul as king, he soon began
undermining Saul's authority, on the excuse that Saul failed to
slaughter all prisoners. 2 Samuel anointed David as a second king, and then
played them against each other 3
to destroy the kingship in order to return him and his sons to
power. Samuel died before he could succeed.
Saul, being the first king, without precedent or training, from an
insignificant Benjamite family, was distraught with lack of
confidence, making him indecisive and causing his military rabble to
lose confidence in him. Chosen to fail, by cunning Sam. Saul sought
help by divination and contacting the dead Samuel. 4
His recurrent depressive episodes were intensified by paranoia,
because if his enemies did not kill him in the battlefield, then his
generals or relatives might kill him at home. 5
Saul could be diagnosed as having had borderline personality
disorder, that is, dramatic shifts between extremes in social
relationships, from love to hate and back again.
According to the Hebrew Bible's Book of Samuel, the preferred king is
one nominated by I-am usually through a prophet, and then
voted in by the tribal leaders, but in reality it was the army who
chose. [2Sam 19.14-18 where men = soldiers] The powers of the king
were curbed by the ambitions of the priests who wrote into The Law
that the Levites were priestly assistants, and the Aaronites the
priests. The priests also controlled the supreme judiciary, the
Sanhedrin, and protected their favored prophets. By writing the
history of kings into the Scriptures, the priests manipulated their
propaganda to suit their own ambition for revenue and power. The
kings tried to limit the power of the priests but, given the
popularity of regicide, needed their support.
The king could lead military campaigns or choose a commander. Since
the royal guard often swore allegiance to the king's son, kingship
became hereditary although there was usually a lethal fight for the
position between siblings. There was no dominant city-state in Israelite hill-country to favor
the rise of a single king. Each town had its warlord, erroneously
called 'king' by the Hebrew Bible. Any warlord had to be elected by
the collective voting of clans and extended-family settlements. In
their turn the warlords voted for a king in wartime. However,
warlords often changed their minds. During war they even changed
sides or downed tools in order to grab loot. This fickleness explains
warlord David's difficulties with his rebellious son Absalom.
Across the 10th to 8th centuries, kings used conscript labor to build
fortresses in rural areas, and at the end of the 8th century,
Hezekiah (716 - 687bc) concentrated the rural population in a series
of fortresses, thus gaining direct control of tax-collection,
conscription for war and public works, and the judicial system; and
thus breaking the power of the patriarchs of rural settlements.
Kosher is used for foods and vessels for food which are ritually permitted under Jewish Law. The priests, as the only source of kosher knowledge, increased their power and revenue (from fines). God had nothing to do with it. [Lev 11 (meat); 17 (blood); 1Sam 14.32-33, etc]
The Law, as the intellectual property of priests, increased their
power and revenue, dictating quantity, quality and frequency of
sacrifices, tithes and fines, and defined their power. Through the
Law the priests defined the powers of certain clans and their
privileges, and made themselves prosecutor, judge and jury of
citizens, with the ultimate power of stoning to death. This was a
theocratic totalitarian society at its worst. God did not write the
Law; the Israelites did not write the Law; the Judean priests did -
those inbred parasites of Jerusalem.
The concentration of administrative and religious power into
Jerusalem, paved the way for High Priest Hilkiah to publish his
rendition of The Law, an early version of Deuteronomy in
621bc.The Pentateuch would not be finished till the post-exilic period
(post-536bc). This contradicts Deuteronomy 1 which
claims that the Book of Moses was to be kept with the Covenant Box
and read every 7 years to all. Such a sacred text, direct from God,
could not have been mislaid for 400 years and then suddenly
discovered during Hilkiah's spring cleaning, since the Temple had
virtually nothing in it except the Covenant Box … and given Moses'
instruction: (The king) is to have the book of God's laws and teachings made
from the original copy kept by the levitical priests. He is to keep
this book near him and read it all his life … . 2
The sudden 'discovery' in 621bc in Josiah's reign confirms that
Hilkiah's Deuteronomy was the first edition of The Law of Mythical
Moses. It could be called, more appropriately, The Law of
Jerusalem in 621bc as recorded by Hilkiah.
The Law is a set of laws by which believers must abide or atone for
their mistakes or be stoned to death. The largest part of The Law
concerns how to keep the Zadokite priests and their Levite
assistants, fat and wealthy. 3 The term 'believers' is inappropriate
because the religion was imposed from above under threat of death.
The religion was restricted to Judea, except when the Hasmonean
dynasty of 142-63bc imposed it on Samaria and Galilee until freed by
Rome, 63bc.
(This supplements the previous chapter The Bible, heading Hebrew Bible, first half.) Pentateuch is Greek for 5 Books and is usually called the 5 Books of Moses because they are about Moses, but they were not written by Moses in spite of what Deut 31.9 says. However, like the Egyptians and Mesopotamians, their kings had recorded their regal histories in books later destroyed by invaders. The Hebrew Bible referenced those books but added fiction and distorted much more, so that it is difficult to separate fact from fiction. How frustrating.
Exodus: The story in the Hebrew Bible is obviously false. The authoring of Exodus and its many re-writings, were done by many people over about 7 centuries, as demonstrated by the fragmentary nature, the inconsistencies and contradictions of its narrative. As three examples:
The Pentateuch begins a pessimistic depressing religion, Judaism,
empty of spirituality, scarce on morality, profuse with
immorality; a religion for a god filled with jealousy, anger, hate
and revenge. What has this done to the psyche of Jews ? Whose
sick minds invented the Passover, the genocide throughout Canaan, the
repeated mass murders and human sacrifices ? Why ? And, most of all, why do Jews continue to worship such an evil god ?
As quoted by Richard Dawkins,
Good people do good deeds; evil
people do evil deeds; but for good people to do evil deeds, it takes
religion.
Israel's apartheid to provoke retaliation, followed by terrorism and chemical weapons such as napalm, to dispossess
Palestinians illustrates this clearly.
Prophets were men or women believed to have messages from a revered god, usually through dreams or visions, but sometimes through personal conversation. 1 God defined true prophets as those who never made false prophecies. 2
Prophets often specialized:
In contrast the High Priest used the Urim and Thummim for divination. 10
Prophets came in different groupings: 1
The Bible's Prophets are separated into:
Books of the Late Prophets:
Dates are guesswork.
** The Book of Isaiah, named after a great prophet of c.740-700, but
written later as 3 sections:
We find a rare exhortation for morality:
See that justice
is done - help those who are oppressed; give orphans their rights;
and defend widows. … (Jerusalem) your leaders are rebels and
friends of thieves; always accepting gifts and bribes. They never
defend orphans in court or listen when widows present their case. 1
Prophets could come from any class or occupation provided they
attained credibility and promoted Deuteronomic Law. In 1Sam 10.1-7,
Samuel explains how to check his credentials as a prophet. The Age of
the Prophets coincides roughly with the Age of Kings, beginning with
Prophet Samuel for King Saul. 2
Before that, successful Judges played the role of prophet by knowing
what I-am thought, helped by the Urim and Thummim. 3
Most prophets warned kings and public that they were being
unfaithful, and that I-am would send war, pestilence or famine to
punish them. Threatening kings would be a very risky occupation. 4
The Hebrew Bible indicates that kings often had hundreds of prophets,
for each god, but fails to explain why a king would or could
support so many parasites. 5
The Bible's prophets habitually denounced other competing prophets. 6
From
775 to 587 they hassled Kings such as Hezekiah and Josiah to destroy
other cults – priests hate competition for revenue. Unusually, Prophets Micah and Isaiah preached that God
wanted, not sacrifices and ritual, but justice and mercy for the
suffering:- stop stealing from the poor; 7 stop land-grabbing, which was dispossession of the poor. 8
Isaiah's most famous prophecy was:
The day will come when nations
will beat their swords into plow shares, and spears into pruning
hooks; nation will not lift up sword against nation, neither will
they learn war any more. 9
Since swords and spears were
never recycled into plow shares and pruning hooks, and yet war
remains more fashionable than all of them, we realise this is another
false prophesy, which, by I-am's definition,
makes Isaiah a false prophet. (Since Isaiah was written
centuries after his death, any true prophecies were by hindsight.) For false prophecies try 1Sam 9.16; 31.1-6; 2Sam 7.10-11,13,16; 23.5;
Micah 2.2-5; Haggai 2.7; Zeph 3.13; Zechariah 1.17; 2.5;
8.3;9.10;14.9,12; Malachi 4 . . . many more in most Books.
How many times have you heard churchgoers say, "But the Bible must be the Word of God because of all those prophecies which came true." Which prophecies came true ?
Prophecies were of three types:
Prophecies-by-hindsight, those written after the event had already occurred:
False prophecies, of which there are many. God I-am covers himself by saying that a prophet is false if his predictions are false. Unfortunately for I-am, His own prophecies, like his promises, are often false, as in Gen 15.18; 17.8; 18.18; Ex 24.26; 34.24; 1Kings 22.23; 2Kings 22.20, 29
But wait ! There's more:
Deut 18.9-22
defines prophets to be avoided, and how to recognize a prophet chosen
by I-am. A true prophet is recognized by giving only true prophecies
- how cute. How can you tell when prophecies are true, when they fail
to specify a future date of occurrence ? According to I-am's
own definition, since most of His own prophecies are false, God is a
false prophet.
2Sam 7.16 God declares: David, you will always have descendants, and
I will make your kingdom last forever. Your dynasty will never end.
God is a false prophet.
Satan 1 In spite of what Christian priests say, the snake in Genesis was not Satan. 'Satan' was a general term applied to any angel objecting, contradicting or obstructing, but not as an angel directing someone to cause evil. An angel is an immortal, a son of God and a heavenly being. Satan, just another son of God, is first mentioned in 1Chron 21.1 as telling David to take a census. In the same story in 2Sam 24.1, God, not Satan, commands David to take that same census and then He slaughters 70,000 of David's people because David obeyed His command. Macabre ? Read it. Chronicles was written towards 458bc while Samuel was written in the 600s but finalized by 536bc. 2 This implies that Satan evolved in the 400s by Jews familiar with Zoroastrianism from Persia. The Roman Church version seems to have evolved from the Zoroastrian Evil-God living in a fiery hell, to scare churchgoers into paying more money. Surprised ?
Every town had its temple to El and other temples. Supposedly, Solomon made Zadok the hereditary High Priest of his Temple of Jerusalem, just 27m x 9m x 13.5m high, the area of 2 small houses, roofless, nothing special. 1 Or you could have the 2Chron 3.3-4 version which is 54 metres high, six times the 9m width; looking ridiculously like an office block, and mightily dangerous given the Palestinian stonemasons of 1Kings 20.29-30. Nonetheless, Solomon, like David, was centralising worship of El in Jerusalem:
Solomon's successor, Jeroboam, suspicious of the Levite scribes and record-keepers loyal to the warlords he had just brought down, evicted the Levite priests from Israel. The Temple of Jerusalem, the psalms tell us, was dedicated to El, but also housed shrines to Ba'al and Astarte. 2
(From HS p914.) Teraphim were pagan household gods, probably in human form, venerated because they were guardians and givers of good fortune. Teraphim were an integral part of meso-pagan worship for individuals, 1 and were therefore destroyed by Josiah in his religious reform 2 but they reappeared after the Exile, 3 showing that paganism was integral to Judean life.
The Day of Atonement, on the 10th day of the 7th month (Sept/Oct) was the day of the jubilee year (50th year) when slaves were freed, debts cancelled and land returned to their original owners. This is now converted to contributions to the needy. Beginning 10 days before, on the New Year, God judges each person's past to decide who will live and who will die over the next year. His judgment finishes on Yom Kippur.
The Persians took Babylon in 539bc, freeing the Judean exiles, but
infected them with Persian Zoroastrianism. Zarathustra (d.528bc)
invented a theology which inspired the Persian monarchy, railing
against the gods of polytheism as evil demons, against sacrifices
(!), magic and idolatry.
He replaced them with a contest of good versus evil. Our hero
Ahura-Mazda, creator of Heaven and Earth, opposed by Ahriman, the
baddie. Everyone is part of this struggle between good and evil, and
our efforts determine our afterlife, of either heavenly bliss or
everlasting fire.
While the prophet Daniel supposedly lived in Babylon till 536bc, the
Book of Daniel belongs post-300bc. It refers to resurrection [12.2],
and separates the good and the bad in the afterlife. Presumably the
Chroniclers also came under Zarathustra's spell. Although God
gave Daniel the skill to interpret dreams in Dan 1.17, his dreams in
12.5-12 proved him to be a false prophet, so his claim that an angel
told him of the resurrection of the dead, should be discounted. Obviously Zarathustra's Heaven and Hell were copied by the Pharisees,
Christians and Moslems. The Christians incorporated Ahriman in Satan.
The struggle between God and an evil Demiurge passed into Gnosticism,
influencing the Gospel of Thomas. Did Jesus also believe ? Metzger 1
notes that the differences between Judaic and Christian scriptures
are:
the incorporation of Jesus as God's locum judge (although Jesus never told anyone):