If I had been on the Exodus, and seen the sea open to let me pass through, and seen the stones upon which God had engraved the 10 Commandments with his finger, and walked behind God Yhwh hidden in the pillar of cloud drifting across the Sinai, my descendants would forever be fervent followers of Yhwh. That the Israelites were fervent followers of El of Bethel and El of Dan, instead of Yhwh of Jerusalem, reveals someone is lying. Could the myth-makers be the money-hungry priests of Jerusalem ?
The distance from the Egyptian Ramses to Jerusalem is about 400km, a distance I have walked in 9 days in autumn/spring. (Summer is too hot; winter days are too short.) The Sinai is a small desert, with, in those times, many roads heavily used by traders, nomadic pastoralists escaping drought or selling their products, and military because Egypt kept a row of forts stretching as far as Canaan (Palestine). Query: Where did the sea for the Exodus come from ? Had Moses lost his compass or lost his marbles ? There isn't any sea. Going east from Ramses, there is nothing but desert. Roads going south would not have gone near Bitter Lakes. The authors were completely ignorant of the geography involved, so the story is fiction. The parting of the waters by Mythical Moses is nonsense.
The Hebrew Scriptures record the popularity of Ba'al-of-the-Covenant, from before Gideon's death in 1209bc 1 which correlates with the mythical Exodus of c.1224bc. 2 What an amazing coincidence ! The Israelites worshiped Ba'al-of-the-Covenant who obviously had a covenant with them at the time of Exodus. But it was during Exodus that Yhwh was supposed to have made a covenant with the Israelites. Who said so ? Did the Israelites make this claim ? No ! It was the Judeans who made this claim, and made it after 587bc, after the Israelites had disappeared into Assyria in 722, when the Israelites could no longer declare it to be a priestly lie. A thinking person might begin to suspect the deliberate fabrication of a myth - the making of a god-scam. Are you thinking ?
If 1Kings 6.1 is used to calculate the date of the Exodus then it began in 1446. Strangely, five years later, in 1441 Pharaoh Amenophis II took 3600 Hapiru captive. Later texts state Hapiru captives were used as servants and stone hauliers. Reconcile this with the Exodus in 1446, without being too strict on dates.
If the Exodus occurred as explained by the Scriptures, from the town of Rameses, and therefore in the reign of Pharaoh Rameses II (also Ramesses) (1304-1237), then the Israelites left c.1250, arrived in 1210, only to be conquered in Canaan by Pharaoh Merenptah in 1220, as recorded on his stele, some ten years before they arrived. Difficult. If the dates are amiss, the Scriptures forgot to record this debilitating setback to Joshua's rampage through Canaan. Or is it just another priestly lie ?
Did 2 million Israelite slaves escape from Egypt ? Really ? The census in both Num 1.46 and Num 26.51 give 600,000 warriors, between 20 and 60 years. Assume the same number of women. To keep replacing adults you need at least 600,000 children between birth and 20 years. Given the high mortality of children, add 200,000. People between 60 and 120 would be at least 200,000 (given biblical longevity). That adds up to:2.2 million = 600,000 men + 600,000 women + 800,000 children + 200,000 over-60s.This gives some logistic problems:
How do foreigners arrive in Canaan, and take city after city, slaughtering every man, woman and child, without leaving archaeological evidence of:
In addition:
Obviously the Exodus, as recorded in the Torah, could never have
happened. We can ignore the claims of Exodus that Moses smote the
water with a four-b-two till it parted, and then they walked across
on dry ground. Forget the wave-the-magic-wand bit. Let us never
forget that we are intelligent people searching the Bible for clues
guiding us to our spiritual development. Genesis and Exodus are
collections of traditional stories snatched from Sumerian,
Mesopotamian and Egyptian religions to fill the gaps in the story of
Jewish priests and God making a contract of loyalty to each other, as
expressed by buying God's protection with sacrifices and tithes. In
spite of 900 pages cluttered with dubious history …
the whole Bible is about paying sacrifices and tithes to the priests
…
… or be killed by I-am.
Cook your sacrificial meat well because I-am likes the smell
of burning flesh. Read Ex 29.18,25,41; Lev 1.9,13,17; 2.2,9; 3.5,16; 4.31; 8.21; Num
28.13,24,27; 29.2,8,13,36 …
Israelis today (2013) are using napalm bombs on Palestinians,
designed to stick burning napalm to the skin so it burns through into
the flesh … of everyone, including innocent children. Both Israelis
and their God love that smell of burning flesh.
Can we reconcile the archaeological evidence, the Egyptian records,
and common sense with the Biblical narrative ? Possibly, but
will the Jews let us ? Definitely not, because that would deny
their Zionist aim to dispossess all Palestinians.
In 1441 Pharaoh Amenophis II took 3600 Hapiru captive. Later texts
state Hapiru captives were used as servants and stone hauliers, which
agrees with the Bible. In 1210 Pharaoh Merenptah defeated the Hapiru
Israelites and took 'royal' hostages, perhaps descendants
of patriarchs Levi and Aaron. These hostages, after the reign of
Merenptah, then led the descendants of the earlier Hapiru back to
Canaan, perhaps c.1170bc in time for the Judges and Saul's
reign, 1030–1010.
The Sinai is small, and many nomadic families and traders walked
across it. The Hapiru were servants and labourers, not slaves, and
their descendants would have been free to leave, like any nomads.
Even slaves are freed after a specified servitude. Or they can buy
their freedom.
When they returned to Canaan, they may have been accepted by their
clans into their ancestral lands, without any need to fight. Or, as
the Scriptures suggest, having been so long away they may have been
forced to use violence to re-establish their claims. If those
returning Levites and Aaronites had learnt special skills such as
literacy and accounting while in Egypt's royal court, they
could have exercised considerable influence on political and
religious development by winning influential positions under
illiterate patriarchs and warlords.
With so few people, there would be no significant archaeological
evidence, cultural or military, which suits the facts if not the
Bible story. They continued Canaanite worship of El,
but used their literacy to manipulate religion to their advantage. 6
And you can take it from there, Sam.
That scenario is hypothetical, but, being based on known facts while
omitting the impossibles, it becomes credible. The worship on Mt
Sinai and the chipping away at stones for 40 days, and waiting 40
years, and eating only mannah, and clothes never wearing out, and
no-one dying and … have all been omitted as unnecessary fictional
narrative that alienates people who think.
All we need to do now is to remove Levite/Zadokite propaganda of
perpetual slaughter of innocents, to convert I-am from the
evil demiurge, to the loving god El, a god of forgiveness,
compassion and morality; the sort of god that you and I could
worship. Such censorship will shrink the Bible from 900 to 50 pages -
which would be very easy to understand.
An exodus is an emigration of a large number of people. Horse-borne tribes from the steppes of central Asia crossed the Caucasus or followed the rivers into western Afghanistan, slaughtering settlers, driving them on. Thus many refugees had tales of an exodus.
The Hapiru, the forebears of the Israelites, were a motley collection of refugees driven south along the route taken by mythical Abraham, 1900 –1500bc, bringing the Law of Hammurabi, tales of the Flood with their Ark beaching on Mt Ararat in Anatolia, a Garden of Eden between the Euphrates and Tigris, and nomadic wanderings with skirmishes as they searched for suitable land. Most of Genesis and Exodus can be found in their wanderings. Some would have gone as far as orderly Egypt, but be driven back to hilly Canaan where plundering was less risky. Tales of Towers of Babel or ziggurats came from Babylon.
If their exodus was from the north why would the Bible's Exodus be from Egypt in the south ? Because Egypt had taken Hapiru captives and their descendants were later released. Their return became embedded in oral history. The stories were combined and muddled by oft-repeated telling, becoming mythology used as the basis for the god-scam, which others call 'religion'.
Palestine, being on valued trade routes, was forever destined to be
invaded by mighty Empires. Instead of uniting to develop an economy
strong enough to pay tribute to some great power for protection,
Judea and Israel's warlords were forever at war among themselves, destroying
crops and livestock and labor, and wasting wealth with petty
squabbling to inflate the egos of its short-lived warlords.
The Annals of Kings, distorted by the Bible, are lost. Were
they destroyed by the Zadokites to conceal their manipulation of
history within the Bible ? The Hebrew Bible, being propaganda,
is not history, but reveals the motives of priests who wrote it, not
in 1440bc but after 700bc.
It is difficult to decide whether the Jews were sent to punish
Yahweh, or Yahweh to punish the Jews. All we can say is
that they deserved each other.